Prop 65 California

Lowe's Settles Lead Dust Violations for $500K, Implements Compliance Program

April 16, 2014
Image: 

Lowe’s Home Centers, one of the nation’s largest home improvement retailers, has agreed to implement a corporate-wide compliance program at more than 1,700 stores nationwide to ensure its contractors minimize lead dust from home renovation activities, as required by the federal Lead Renovation, Repair and Painting (RRP) Rule, the Department of Justice and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) announced today.  The company will also pay a $500,000 civil penalty, which is the largest ever for violations of the RRP Rule.

The government complaint alleged that Lowe’s failed to provide documentation showing that its contractors had been certified by EPA, had been properly trained, had used lead-safe work practices, or had correctly used EPA-approved lead test kits at renovation sites.   Additionally, EPA’s investigation found that Lowe’s contractors had failed to ensure that work areas had been properly contained and cleaned during renovations.  EPA’s investigation was prompted by tips and complaints submitted by the public.

In addition to the civil penalty, Lowe’s must implement a comprehensive compliance program to ensure that the contractors it hires to perform work for its customers comply with the RRP Rule during renovations of any child-occupied facilities, such as day-care centers and schools, and any housing that was built before 1978.  For these projects, Lowe’s must contract with only EPA-certified renovators, ensure they maintain certification, and ensure they use lead safe work practices checklists during renovations.  In addition, Lowe’s must suspend anyone that is not operating in compliance with the rule, investigate all reports of potential noncompliance, and ensure that any violations are corrected.

The RRP Rule, which implements the federal Toxic Substances Control Act, is intended to ensure that owners and occupants of housing built before 1978, as well as any child-occupied facilities, receive information on lead-based paint hazards before renovations begin, and that individuals performing such renovations are properly trained and certified by EPA and follow specific work practices to reduce the potential for lead-based paint exposure.  Home improvement companies such as Lowe’s that contract with renovators to perform renovation work must ensure that those contractors comply with all of the requirements of the RRP Rule.  Renovators that are certified under EPA’s RRP Rule are encouraged to display EPA’s “Lead-Safe” logo on worker’s uniforms, signs, websites and other material, as appropriate.   Consumers can protect themselves by looking for the logo before hiring a home renovator.

Lead-based paint was banned in 1978 but still remains in many homes and apartments across the country.  Lead dust hazards can occur when lead paint deteriorates or is disrupted during home renovation and remodeling activities.   Lead exposure can cause a range of health problems, from behavioral disorders and learning disabilities to seizures and death, putting young children at the greatest risk because their nervous systems are still developing.  Lead is a chemical known to the State of California to cause cancer, birth defects, and reproductive harm.

The Chanler Group represents citizen enforcers who, acting in the public interest, commence actions against businesses offering products for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive harm without first providing the health hazard warning required by Proposition 65. Citizen enforcers bringing Proposition 65 actions in the public interest may obtain a Court Judgment imposing civil penalties, an injunction requiring reformulation of products, and/or provision of health hazard warnings. The Chanler Group has represented citizen enforcers of Proposition 65 for more than twenty years.

Cross-Post On: 
Both

TCG Clients Serve 32 New 60-Day Notices of Proposition 65 Violation

April 17, 2014

TCG clients Russell Brimer, Dr. Whitney Leeman, Dr. Anthony Held, Mark Moorberg, Laurence Vinocur, and Paul Wozniak served over 30 new 60-Day Notices of Proposition 65 Violation yesterday, to companies offering products such as sunscreen, hardware, and children's purses  for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause cancer and reproductive harm, without the required health hazard warning. These citizen enforcers allege that the companies' products contain the phthalate DEHP, the heavy metals lead and arsenic, the flame retardant TDCPP, and the chemical benzophene.  DEHP and lead are known to cause birth defects and reproductive harm, while arsenic, TDCPP, and benzophene are known to cause cancer. Some of the noticed companies include CVS Caremark Corporation, Jamba Juice Company, and Rite Aid Corporation.

See below for a partial list of notices.

Product Chemical Alleged Violator Citizen Enforcer
Sunscreen Benzophenone CVS Caremark Corporation; CVS Pharmacy, Inc. Held
Metal Hose Fittings Lead FNA Group, Inc. Moorberg
Vinyl/PVC Pants DEHP Invacare Corporation Moorberg
Pedometers with Vinyl/PVC ID Holders DEHP Jamba Juice Company; Jamba, Inc.  Moorberg
Vinyl/PVC Aprons DEHP Liberty Glove, Inc. Moorberg
Tools with Vinyl/PVC Grips DEHP Lincoln Electric Holdings, Inc.; The Lincoln Electric Company; J. W. Harris Co., Inc. Moorberg
Dried Seaweed Arsenic Natural Import Company Inc.; Mitoku Company, Ltd. Held
Vinyl/PVC Wire Mesh Gates DEHP North States Industries, Inc. Moorberg
Mugs with Vinyl/PVC Sleeves DEHP Polyconcept North America, Inc.; Leedsworld, Inc.  Moorberg
Candle Wax Warmers with Exterior Designs Lead Rimports (USA) LLC Moorberg
Sunscreen Benzophenone Rite Aid Corporation Held
Vinyl/PVC Clutches DEHP; Lead Spectrum Imports, Inc.; McCaulou's, Inc. Moorberg
Children's Purses Lead Tara Toy Corp. Moorberg
Sunscreen Benzophenone Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. Held
Vinyl/PVC Tubing DEHP Watts Water Technologies, Inc. Moorberg
Vinyl/PVC Tubing DEHP Zircon Corporation Moorberg

.

Cross-Post On: 
Both

Four Seasons Reformulates Bowls Thanks to Work of Dr. Held

April 8, 2014
Image: 

Dr. Anthony Held, a client of The Chanler Group, negotiated an agreement with Four Seasons General Merchandise in February to ensure that its bowls are free of the toxic metal lead. 

Held alleged that Four Seasons violated Proposition 65 by selling bowls that contain lead in California without providing a health hazard warning.  Under Proposition 65, companies offering products for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive harm must provide a health hazard warning.

As part of the agreement, Four Seasons agreed to reformulate all of its bowls to virtually eliminate lead.  Four Seasons will also pay civil penalties of $20,000, 75 percent of which are earmarked for California’s Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment.  

For more information about the agreement, please see the case summary on the website.

The Chanler Group represents citizen enforcers who, acting in the public interest, commence actions against businesses offering products for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive harm without first providing the health hazard warning required by Proposition 65.  Citizen enforcers bringing Proposition 65 actions in the public interest may obtain a Court Judgment imposing civil penalties, an injunction requiring reformulation of products, and/or provision of health hazard warnings.  The Chanler Group has represented citizen enforcers of Proposition 65 for more than twenty years.

Cross-Post On: 
Both

TCG Clients Serve 31 New 60-Day Notices of Proposition 65 Violation

March 26, 2014

TCG clients Russell Brimer, Dr. Anthony Held, Dr. Whitney Leeman, Laurence Vinocur, and Paul Wozniak served over 30 new 60-Day Notices of Proposition 65 Violation today, to companies offering products such as hand tools, sunscreen, and bags for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause cancer and reproductive harm, without the required health hazard warning. These citizen enforcers allege that the companies' products contain the phthalate DEHP, the heavy metals lead and arsenic, the flame retardant TDCPP, and the chemicals benzophene and 4,4’MDA.  DEHP and lead are known to cause birth defects and reproductive harm, while arsenic, TDCPP, 4,4’MDA, and benzophene are known to cause cancer. Some of the noticed companies include Allway Tools, Herman Pearl Company, Levlad LLC, Target Corporation, and Toys “R” Us.

See below for a partial list of notices.

Product

Chemical

Alleged Violator

Citizen Enforcer

Vinyl/PVC Cosmetic Cases

DEHP

A-List, Inc.

Wozniak

Tools with Vinyl/PVC Grips

DEHP

Allway Tools, Inc.

Wozniak

Boat Hooks with
Vinyl/PVC Grips

DEHP

Brunswick Corporation; Attwood Corporation

Wozniak

Stools with Vinyl/PVC Upholstery containing DEHP; Earphones with Vinyl/PVC Cords containing DEHP

DEHP

Central Purchasing, LLC; Harbor Freight Tools USA, Inc.

Wozniak

Footwear with Vinyl/PVC Straps

DBP

Creedence Holdings LLC; Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.

Wozniak

Vinyl/PVC Automobile Seat Covers

DEHP

Danaher Corporation; NMTC, Inc.

Wozniak

Vinyl/PVC Toiletry Bags

DEHP

Dentek Oral Care, Inc.

Wozniak

Vinyl/PVC Storage Baskets; Vinyl/PVC Pencil Pouches;
Tape Measures with Vinyl/PVC Hand Straps; Metal Tape Measures

DEHP; LEAD

Dollar General Corporation; Dolgencorp, LLC

Wozniak

Upholstered  Chairs with Foam Padding containing TDCPP; Chairs with Vinyl/PVC Upholstery containing DEHP

TDCPP; DEHP

Guidecraft, Inc.; Target Corporation

Vinocur

Vinyl/PVC Aprons

DEHP

Herman Pearl Company

Wozniak

Tools with Vinyl/PVC Grips

DEHP

Leviton Manufacturing Co., Inc.

Wozniak

Sunscreen

Benzophenone

Levlad, LLC; Sprouts Farmers Market, Inc.

Held

Glass Jar with Exterior Designs containing Lead

LEAD

LF USA Inc.

Wozniak

Glass Containers for Reed Diffusers with Exterior Designs containing Lead

LEAD

Ross Stores, Inc.

Wozniak

LED Lights with Vinyl/PVC Cables

DEHP

Seasonal Specialties LLC; Target Corporation

Brimer

Vinyl/PVC Bracelets

DEHP

Supervalu Inc.; Winco Holdings, Inc.; Winco Foods, LLC

Wozniak

Nylon Cooking Utensils

4,4'MDA

Tailor Made Products, Inc.; Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.

Wozniak

Sunscreen

Benzophenone

Target Corporation

Held

Headphones with Vinyl/PVC Cushions

DEHP

Toys "R" Us, Inc.

Wozniak

Read the most recent notices issued by clients of The Chanler Group

Cross-Post On: 
Both

Flame Retardant Mfr Sues Over TB-117 Revision

March 20, 2014
Image: 

Chemtura, a leading manufacturer of flame retardants and other chemicals, filed suit earlier this year regarding the recent revision to the decades-old Technical Bulletin 117 (TB-117), reported the San Francisco ChronicleTB-117-2013 revises TB-117 in such a way that furniture manufacturers may no longer have to douse their products in carcinogenic flame retardant chemicals.

Previously, TB-117 required that the foam padding inside upholstered furniture sold in California be able to withstand an open flame test, which led many furniture manufacturers to treat their products with flame retardants.  The flame retardants migrated from the furniture and into household and office dust, where it entered people’s bodies.  Since 1975, when TB-117 was adopted, a Chicago Tribune exposé has led many to question the efficacy of these flame retardants, especially since they have been shown to have adverse health effects, including developmental harm and increased risk of cancer.

In the revision, furniture sold in California are now subject to a smolder test on the upholstery rather than the foam padding within.  It eliminates the need for toxic flame retardants and, according to officials, will maintain or even improve consumer safety.  TB-117-2013 will take effect in the beginning of 2015.

Chemtura alleges that the standard weakens fire safety and that the number of fires caused by small, open flames is significant.

The Chanler Group represents citizen enforcers who, acting in the public interest, commence actions against businesses offering products for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive harm without first providing the health hazard warning required by Proposition 65. Citizen enforcers bringing Proposition 65 actions in the public interest may obtain a Court Judgment imposing civil penalties, an injunction requiring reformulation of products, and/or provision of health hazard warnings. The Chanler Group has represented citizen enforcers of Proposition 65 for more than twenty years.

Cross-Post On: 
Both

Court Denies Defendant Bexco’s Motion to Strike, Upholding Scope of Plaintiff’s Allegations in Complaint

March 14, 2014
Image: 

On Jan. 10, 2014, the Hon. George C. Hernandez, Jr. denied Bexco’s Motion to Strike portions of TCG client Peter Englander’s complaint, leaving intact Englander’s allegations in the complaint that all upholstered furniture products with foam padding containing the Proposition 65-listed chemical flame retardant tris(1,3-dichloro-2-propyl) phosphate (“TDCPP”) manufactured by Bexco are sources of potential Proposition 65 violations and covered by Englander’s 60-Day Notice of Violation. 

Bexco contended that Englander’s notice applied only to the specific exemplar product, a gliding rocker identified as the Da Vinci Classic Sleigh Glider and Ottoman, and accused Englander of trying to “expand the reach of this private action far beyond a fair reading of that 60-Day Notice, to include all Bexco furniture that can be shoehorned into a generic description.”  Bexco would require TCG’s client to purchase and test at least one of each Bexco product he wishes to have included in the lawsuit.

In his opposition to the motion, TCG attorney Brian Johnson countered that Englander provided Bexco with “notice of its alleged violations in a manner that exceeds the form and content required by the statute” and that Bexco can “very easily discern what type of products are allegedly in violation, because Plaintiff has provided the product category of ‘upholstered furniture’.”  For Bexco to suggest that Englander must issue a notice for every piece of Bexco’s furniture that is in violation of Proposition 65 is “simply not the law.”

In denying Bexco’s Motion to Strike, Judge Hernandez noted as set forth in Englander’s opposition that “no authority requires a putative plaintiff to identify the specific component of a product containing a toxic chemical…describing the product category or type in terms of common usage or understanding is sufficient.”  He went on to write, “…nor does this complaint suggest the kind of speculative, scattershot notices utilized by ‘bounty hunters’ [in cases Bexco claimed analogous]…It identifies specific items manufactured by the Defendant, specifically identifies two exemplars that have been tested and plaintiff contends contain listed chemicals, and identifies the retailers who sold these exemplars to plaintiff.”

In light of the Court’s denial the case will proceed on the Court’s trial calendar, and Bexco is potentially liable for all of its TDCPP-containing upholstered furniture sold without a Proposition 65 warning in California after October 28, 2012, when the warning requirement for TDCPP took effect.  Englander’s enforcement of the alleged violations continues as the parties evaluate potential resolutions in the public interest.

The Chanler Group represents citizen enforcers who, acting in the public interest, commence actions against businesses offering products for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive harm without first providing the health hazard warning required by Proposition 65. Citizen enforcers bringing Proposition 65 actions in the public interest may obtain a Court Judgment imposing civil penalties, an injunction requiring reformulation of products, and/or provision of health hazard warnings. The Chanler Group has represented citizen enforcers of Proposition 65 for more than twenty years.

Cross-Post On: 
Both

Governor Brown Proposes $765K for Prop 65

March 12, 2014
Image: 

California Governor Jerry Brown’s proposed 2014-2015 budget will allocate $765,000 to the California Environmental Protection Agency’s Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA).  The money will allow OEHHA to revise the Proposition 65 warning regulations and develop a new website.

Proposition 65, or The Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, requires companies offering products for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive harm to provide consumers with a health hazard warning.  Last year, Governor Brown announced a plan to to revise Prop 65, which is still under consideration.  The Governor’s reform efforts followed on the heels of an amendment sponsored by Assemblyman Mike Gatto, which gives some businesses a 14-day cure period.  OEHHA is also considering revisions to its regulations concerning Proposition 65 warnings.

The Chanler Group represents citizen enforcers who, acting in the public interest, commence actions against businesses offering products for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive harm without first providing the health hazard warning required by Proposition 65. Citizen enforcers bringing Proposition 65 actions in the public interest may obtain a Court Judgment imposing civil penalties, an injunction requiring reformulation of products, and/or provision of health hazard warnings. The Chanler Group has represented citizen enforcers of Proposition 65 for more than twenty years.

Cross-Post On: 
Both

High Chairs to be Reformulated Thanks to Vinocur’s Work

March 6, 2014
Image: 

Laurence Vinocur, a client of The Chanler Group, negotiated an agreement with Joovy Holding Co. to ensure that Joovy’s high chairs are free of the carcinogenic flame retardant tris(1,3-dichloro-2-propyl) phosphate (TDCPP).  The high chairs were sold throughout California from retailers such as Babies “R” Us and BuyBuy Baby.

Vinocur alleged that Joovy violated Proposition 65 by selling high chairs that contain TDCPP in California without providing a health hazard warning.  Under Proposition 65, companies offering products for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive harm must provide a health hazard warning.

As part of the agreement, Joovy agreed to reformulate all of its high chairs to virtually eliminate TDCPP, and will notify its vendors to sell only the reformulated products.  Joovy will also pay civil penalties of $27,000, 75 percent of which are earmarked for California’s Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment.   As an incentive for comprehensive reformulation, Vinocur will waive a portion of the civil fine should Joovy certify that the high chairs are free of another toxic flame retardant, tris(2,3-dibromopropyl)phosphate (“TDBPP”). 

For more information about the agreement, please see the case summary on the website.

Joovy sells dozens of infant and child products including toys, furniture, and baby carriers.

The Chanler Group represents citizen enforcers who, acting in the public interest, commence actions against businesses offering products for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive harm without first providing the health hazard warning required by Proposition 65.  Citizen enforcers bringing Proposition 65 actions in the public interest may obtain a Court Judgment imposing civil penalties, an injunction requiring reformulation of products, and/or provision of health hazard warnings.  The Chanler Group has represented citizen enforcers of Proposition 65 for more than twenty years.

Cross-Post On: 
Both

TCG Clients Serve 10 New 60-Day Notices

February 27, 2014
Image: 

TCG clients Russell Brimer, Dr. Anthony Held, and Dr. Whitney Leeman served ten new 60-Day Notices of Proposition 65 Violation yesterday, to companies offering products such as hand tools, sunscreen, and bags for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause reproductive harm, without the required health hazard warning. These citizen enforcers allege that the companies' products contain the phthalate DEHP and the chemical benzophene.  DEHP is known to cause birth defects and reproductive harm, while benzophene is known to cause cancer. Some of the noticed companies include Johnson & Johnson, L’Oreal, Merck & Co., and Target Corporation.

See below for a partial list of notices.

Product Chemical Alleged Violator Citizen Enforcer
Tools with Vinyl/PVC Grips DEHP 31, Inc. Leeman
Vinyl/PVC Tape Measure
Hand Straps
DEHP Acme United Corporation Leeman
Vinyl/PVC Cases for Pill/Medication Organizers DEHP Apothecary Products, Inc. Leeman
Seat Cushions with Vinyl/PVC Upholstery DEHP Briggs Medical Service Company Leeman
Vinyl/PVC Luggage Tags DEHP CVS Caremark Corporation Leeman
Vinyl/PVC Bracelets DEHP The Dollfus Mieg Company, Inc. Leeman
Vinyl/PVC Game Cases DEHP Great Lakes Dart Mfg., Inc. Leeman
Sunscreen Benzophenone Johnson & Johnson; Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. Held
Vinyl/PVC Cord Protectors DEHP Legrand Holding, Inc.; The Wiremold Company Leeman
Tools with Vinyl/PVC Grips DEHP Lisle Corporation Leeman
Vinyl/PVC Bags DEHP Little Pim Corporation; Michaels Stores, Inc.; Aaron Brothers, Inc. Brimer
Sunscreen Benzophenone L'Oreal USA, Inc.; Walgreen Co.; Drugstore.com, Inc. Held
Sunscreen Benzophenone Merck & Co., Inc.; Walgreen Co.; Drugstore.com, Inc. Held
Vinyl/PVC Bags;
Vinyl/PVC Zipper Pulls
DEHP Springs Global US, Inc. Brimer
Sunscreen Benzophenone Sun & Skin Care Research, LLC; Sanofi-Synthelabo Inc.; Sanofi-Aventis U.S. LLC; Chattem, Inc.; Target Corporation Held
Vinyl/PVC ID Pouches;
Vinyl/PVC Manicure Cases
DEHP Target Corporation Brimer
Seats wth Vinyl/PVC Upholstery DEHP The Wise Co., Inc. Leeman

Read the most recent notices issued by clients of The Chanler Group

Cross-Post On: 
Both

American Greetings to Reformulate Cards Thanks to TCG Client Whitney Leeman

February 26, 2014
Image: 

Dr. Whitney Leeman, a client of The Chanler Group, obtained an agreement earlier this month to ensure that greeting cards sold by American Greetings will be free of di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate (DEHP), a toxic phthalate chemical known to cause birth defects and other reproductive harm.  Leeman alleged that American Greetings violated Proposition 65 by selling cards made with vinyl/PVC components containing DEHP in California without providing a health hazard warning.  Under Proposition 65, companies offering products for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive harm must provide a health hazard warning.

As part of the agreement, American Greetings will reformulate its cards to virtually eliminate DEHP.  The company will pay civil penalties of $16,500, with 75% of those penalties to be paid to the State of California, to enhance public health and the environment.  To provide an incentive for expediting reformulation, Leeman will waive a portion of the civil penalty if American Greetings certifies by May 1, 2014 that the cards are reformulated.

For more information about the agreement, please see the case summary on the website. 

American Greetings is a billion-dollar corporation that sells greetings cards and other products.

The Chanler Group represents citizen enforcers who, acting in the public interest, commence actions against businesses offering products for sale in California that contain chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive harm without first providing the health hazard warning required by Proposition 65.  Citizen enforcers bringing Proposition 65 actions in the public interest may obtain a Court Judgment imposing civil penalties, an injunction requiring reformulation of products, and/or provision of health hazard warnings.  The Chanler Group has represented citizen enforcers of Proposition 65 for more than twenty years. 

Cross-Post On: 
Both
Syndicate content